What are the advantages and disadvantages of different types of tunnel support methods? Common tunnel support methods include anchor spray support, anchor rods, shotcrete, steel arches, etc., each of which has its own advantages and disadvantages. The following is a specific introduction:
1. Anchor spray support
Advantages: Good flexibility and adaptability to different surrounding rock conditions; Strong timeliness, able to be quickly implemented after excavation; Has close adhesion and can be tightly combined with surrounding rock; Excellent depth, able to penetrate deep into the surrounding rock and play a role; Has a certain degree of flexibility, allowing for appropriate deformation of the surrounding rock; It has good sealing properties and can effectively prevent the weathering and loosening of surrounding rocks.
Disadvantages: Its support effect is greatly affected by construction quality; For particularly weak or unstable surrounding rocks, it may be necessary to combine other support methods.
2. Anchor rod support
Advantages: It can effectively support the surrounding rock and improve its stability; It can strongly reinforce the surrounding rock, increase its strength and bearing capacity; Can increase interlayer frictional resistance and enhance the connection between rock layers; Plays a suspension role to prevent local rock mass from loosening and falling off.
Disadvantages: The anchoring effect of anchor rods is affected by rock conditions, and the anchoring force may be insufficient in some fractured or weak rock masses; Construction requires certain technical and equipment support; In long-term use, the durability of anchor rods may be affected by factors such as corrosion.
3. Spray concrete support
Advantages: It can provide timely support for the surrounding rock and limit its deformation; Has unloading function and can share part of the load borne by the surrounding rock; Can reinforce the surrounding rock and improve its overall integrity; Can cover the surface of the surrounding rock and prevent it from loosening and peeling off; The construction is relatively simple and fast.
Disadvantages: The quality of sprayed concrete is greatly affected by construction techniques and material mix proportions; High rebound rate may result in certain material waste; The technical requirements for construction personnel are high to ensure the uniformity and compactness of spraying.
4. Steel arch support
Advantages: The overall stiffness is relatively high, which has a good supporting effect on fractured rock or rock with low rock grades; Can be made and assembled on site, suitable for tunnels with different cross-sections and conditions; It can be well combined with other support methods such as anchor rods and shotcrete to work together and improve support efficiency.
Disadvantages: Large amount of steel used, relatively high cost; Installation requires a certain amount of time and manpower; The weight of steel arches is relatively large, and the transportation and installation process is relatively complex.
In practical engineering, one or more support methods are usually selected comprehensively based on the specific geological conditions, surrounding rock types, tunnel uses, construction methods, and other factors of the tunnel to achieve safe, economical, and reasonable support effects. At the same time, monitoring and measurement during the construction process are also very important. Based on the monitoring results, support parameters can be adjusted in a timely manner to ensure the stability and safety of the tunnel.